Risk assessment & AML compliance

Inherent Risk: Meaning, Definition & Examples

Inherent risk explained: meaning, definition, AML examples, residual risk comparison, assessment steps, and FINTRAC and U.S. BSA/FinCEN guidance.

On this page
Get Expert Help

Key takeaways

  • Inherent risk is exposure before controls. Residual risk is what remains after controls are applied and judged for effectiveness, and FINTRAC notes that some residual risk always remains.
  • Five factor groups drive the rating. Section 156 of the PCMLTFR requires the assessment to consider clients and business relationships, products, services and delivery channels, geography, new technologies, and other relevant factors.
  • FINTRAC does not prescribe one scoring method. The assessment must be documented, suit the size of the business, and record the reason for each rating.
  • Update it when the business changes. A new product, service, or location is a trigger, and new technologies must be assessed before launch.
  • U.S. MSBs follow a different rule. 31 CFR 1022.210 requires the AML program to be commensurate with the risks of the business's location, size, and the nature and volume of its services.

Inherent risk is the money laundering and terrorist financing risk a business carries before any controls are applied. It describes exposure: who the customers are, what the business sells, how it reaches people, and where the money moves. FINTRAC's risk assessment guidance defines inherent risk as the risk that exists before you put controls in place, and it treats identifying that risk as the first step of the risk-based approach.

What Is Inherent Risk?

In an AML context, inherent risk is the natural level of exposure that comes from how a business operates. A currency exchange that serves walk-in customers and sends funds abroad has a different starting point than a firm that manages a small number of long-standing domestic accounts. Neither starting point says anything yet about how well either firm is run. It only says where the risk sits before staff, systems, and procedures act on it.

The term matters because every later decision depends on it. Controls are chosen to answer a risk that has been named, and a business that skips the inherent risk step usually ends up with generic controls that fit its own operations poorly.

Inherent Risk vs. Residual Risk

Residual risk is what remains after controls are applied. FINTRAC describes it as the risk left after your risk-reduction measures and key controls, and says some residual risk always remains. It also describes two ways to handle it: tolerate it, which means accepting it because reducing it further is not worth the cost, or mitigate it, which means reducing it without removing it.

  • Inherent risk is assessed first, before controls. It answers the question of how exposed the business is.
  • Controls are the policies, screening, monitoring, training, and approvals the business puts in place against each identified risk.
  • Residual risk is assessed last, after judging how well those controls work. It should sit within the business's stated risk tolerance.

A business can have high inherent risk and acceptable residual risk if its controls are strong and tested. The reverse also happens: a low inherent risk business with weak or untested controls can carry more residual risk than it expects.

Why Regulators Expect You to Assess It

In Canada, the legal basis is section 9.6 of the Proceeds of Crime (Money Laundering) and Terrorist Financing Act. Subsection 9.6(2) requires a compliance program that includes policies and procedures to assess the risk of a money laundering or terrorist activity financing offence, and subsection 9.6(3) requires special measures when the entity considers that risk to be high. Section 156 of the Proceeds of Crime (Money Laundering) and Terrorist Financing Regulations sets out what the assessment must cover, and FINTRAC's compliance program guidance adds sanctions evasion risk to the assessment.

FINTRAC does not prescribe one scoring method. Its guidance says reporting entities are responsible for completing and documenting their own assessment, and that the method should match the size and type of the business. The expectation is a reasoned, documented assessment that reflects the business as it actually operates. A template filled in without business data does not meet it.

The Risk Factors FINTRAC Expects You to Consider

Paragraph 156(1)(c) of the Regulations requires the assessment to consider clients and business relationships (including correspondent banking relationships), products, services and delivery channels, the geographic location of activities, and any other relevant factor. For financial entities, life insurance companies, and securities dealers, it also covers risk from affiliates. Under subsection 156(2), the risk of a new development or technology must be assessed and documented before it is introduced. FINTRAC's compliance program guidance also tells reporting entities to take into account the risks that apply to their sector in the latest national risk assessment.

Customers and business relationships

FINTRAC's guidance lists factors that can raise client risk, including a criminal history related to a designated offence, an unknown source of funds, an unknown beneficiary or conductor of a transaction, missing transaction details, and unusual speed, volume, or frequency of activity. Transactions that are complex without a clear explanation also appear on that list. Low activity, low balances, and low-value transactions can lower the rating. Customers who are politically exposed persons or heads of international organizations have their own rules, which are covered in our guide to politically exposed persons in Canada.

Products and services

Products raise inherent risk where they allow client anonymity or make the source of funds hard to establish. FINTRAC's guidance gives international electronic funds transfers, correspondent banking, private banking, precious metals and banknote trading, and casino front money accounts as examples.

Delivery channels

Channels where the customer is not physically present, such as internet, phone, chat applications, virtual currency, and online document signing, are treated as higher risk in FINTRAC's guidance. They can obscure identity and operate at any hour. A business that onboards customers entirely online should rate that channel separately from its in-person branches.

Geography

Geographic risk covers where the business operates and where customers and funds come from or go to. FINTRAC lists funds sent to or received from high-risk jurisdictions, and clients with a material connection to a high-risk country, as higher risk indicators. The business also needs to consider where it has branches, agents, or other operating locations.

New developments and technologies

New products and technologies can add anonymity or speed that existing controls were not built for. FINTRAC's guidance names e-wallets, mobile payments, and virtual currencies as examples. The Regulations require the assessment before launch, so it has to be completed and documented before a new product goes live.

How to Assess and Rate Inherent Risk

FINTRAC describes a risk-based approach cycle: identify inherent risks, set risk tolerance, create risk-reduction measures and key controls, evaluate residual risks, implement, and review. Inherent risk is step one, and a workable process for it looks like this.

  • Split the assessment in two. FINTRAC separates the business-based assessment, which looks at the firm as a whole, from the relationship-based assessment, which rates individual clients.
  • Use your own data. Customer counts by segment, transaction volumes by corridor, share of non-face-to-face onboarding, and number of new products launched all give the rating a factual basis.
  • Pick a scale that fits the size of the business. FINTRAC says very small businesses may use only low and high categories, while larger ones are expected to use more detailed scales.
  • Consider likelihood and impact. FINTRAC's guidance includes a likelihood and impact matrix in which each is rated low, medium, or high.
  • Write down the reason for each rating. The guidance expects the rationale for each factor to be documented.
  • Update it when the business changes. Adding a product, service, or location is a reason to redo the assessment, not wait for the next review.

A single high-risk indicator does not automatically make a client high risk, with a small number of exceptions listed in FINTRAC's guidance. Ratings are a judgment across the full picture, which is why the written rationale matters.

A Worked Example

The example below is illustrative. The business and the ratings are hypothetical and are not a benchmark for any real firm.

A Canadian money services business offers currency exchange at two branches and an online remittance service to three countries. It is assessing inherent risk for the first time.

  • Customers. Most branch customers are walk-in individuals making occasional exchanges. The online service has a growing base of repeat senders. The firm rates walk-in customers medium and repeat senders medium, and notes that it cannot yet explain the source of funds for larger senders.
  • Products and services. Remittance abroad is an international funds transfer, which FINTRAC's guidance lists among higher-risk products. The firm rates remittance high and in-branch exchange medium.
  • Delivery channels. The online service onboards customers without meeting them. The firm rates it high and the branches medium.
  • Geography. One of the three destination countries appears on a high-risk jurisdiction list the firm uses. The firm rates that corridor high and the others medium.
  • New technology. A planned mobile wallet has not launched. The firm records a requirement to complete and document its risk assessment before launch.

The result is a business with several high inherent risk areas concentrated in the online remittance service. The next steps follow directly: set controls for those areas, such as enhanced identity verification for non-face-to-face onboarding, transaction limits on the high-risk corridor, and closer monitoring of larger senders. Then the firm evaluates how well those controls work to reach a residual risk rating. If any element is still rated high after controls, the special measures under subsection 9.6(3) of the Act apply.

Common Mistakes

  • Copying a template. An assessment that names risks the business does not have, and misses the ones it does, will not hold up in an examination.
  • Rating after controls. If the existing controls are already shaping the rating, the document is measuring residual risk and the inherent risk step has been skipped.
  • No written rationale. A rating with no explanation behind it is difficult to defend, whatever the judgment behind it.
  • Ignoring sanctions evasion. FINTRAC's compliance program guidance includes sanctions evasion risk in the assessment alongside money laundering and terrorist financing risk.
  • Treating it as one-off. The assessment should change when the business changes. FINTRAC's guidance says to redo it when a new product, service, or location is added, and the compliance program must be reviewed every two years.
  • Skipping the link to controls. Where the assessment rates something high, the guidance expects documented controls and evidence that they are effective. High-risk clients and relationships call for enhanced measures such as enhanced due diligence.

Inherent Risk for U.S. Money Services Businesses

For money services businesses in the United States, 31 CFR 1022.210 requires an effective anti-money laundering program, and says the program must be commensurate with the risks posed by the location and size of, and the nature and volume of the financial services provided by, the business. That language ties the program to the business's own risk profile, which in practice calls for the same inherent risk analysis described above. Canadian businesses should keep the two frameworks separate, because FINTRAC's requirements apply to Canadian reporting entities regardless of any U.S. rules.

Inherent Risk FAQs

What is the difference between inherent risk and residual risk?

Inherent risk is the exposure before controls. Residual risk is what remains after controls are applied and judged for effectiveness. FINTRAC notes that some residual risk always remains.

Does FINTRAC require a specific inherent risk scoring model?

No. FINTRAC does not prescribe a method. It expects the assessment to be documented, to reflect the business, and to use a scale suited to its size. The factors in section 156 of the Regulations must be considered.

How often should the risk assessment be updated?

FINTRAC's guidance says to update the assessment when the business changes, for example when it adds a product, service, or location. The compliance program, including the risk assessment, must also be reviewed every two years under section 156 of the Regulations.

Where does the national risk assessment fit in?

FINTRAC's compliance program guidance says reporting entities must consider the applicable risks for their sector in the latest national risk assessment. See our summary of the Canadian national risk assessment.

Who tests whether the assessment is adequate?

The two-year effectiveness review checks whether the risk assessment is effective and reflects current operations. An independent AML audit is one way to carry out that review.

ComplyFactor's AML advisory support helps MSBs, PSPs, fintechs, and other regulated businesses build and document risk assessments that reflect how they actually operate.

ComplyFactor Advisory Team

ComplyFactor is a Canadian AML and regulatory compliance advisory firm serving MSBs, PSPs, fintechs and other regulated businesses.

Get started

Book a free compliance consultation?

Tell us about your business and we'll confirm which services you need. Free, no obligation, 30 minutes.

Free, no obligation, 30 minutes
Senior consultant on every engagement
Advice matched to your regulator and jurisdiction
+1 807 806 0444 Β· Suite 211, 320 Matheson Blvd West, Mississauga, ON

Talk to an AML expert

Thank you. Your message has been received. We'll be in touch within one business day.
Something went wrong while submitting the form. Please try again.